Share your failure and win a copy of The Tightwad Gazette
Many frugal zealots consider The Tightwad Gazette by Amy Dacyczyn to be the handbook for frugal living. There is such a wide range of ideas in it that everyone can learn something new. Everyone can also find something that is just too extreme even for them. We all seem to love it or hate it, or both. It's just that good.
I picked up 2 used copies over the weekend. They were $2 each, and I used a $5 off coupon that had no minimum. Yes, I got them both for free. Amy would be proud of me.
My money-saving techniques don't always work out quite so well, though, and I suspect yours don't either. Oh, the stories I could tell...wasted food purchased on sale...the cheap iron that burned up hubby's best dress clothes...skipping the survey and building our house on the wrong property...
Want to win your own copy of The Tightwad Gazette? Share your worst-ever attempt at pinching pennies: your biggest, most embarrassing, funniest or worst failure to show how badly you need the book. Either tell us your story in the comments or link to the story on your own blog (be sure to link to the specific post). Enter as many times as you like - just keep sharing new stories of failure to encourage the rest of us that we're not alone and frugality is worth the hard lessons along the way. You can also enter by telling somebody else's story, but if you win maybe you should consider giving the book to them.
We'll take entries for a week, then we'll choose a winner in a totally unfair and biased method of our choosing. Choosing a random entry is just so predictable.
related posts:
- 2 Giveaways: Tightwad Gazette Could anything be more appropriate for a giveaway on Frugal...
- Giveaway: The Tightwad Gazette Here's your chance to win the bible of frugalites everywhere!...
- Winner of The Tightwad Gazette giveaway Thanks to everyone who shared their tips and entered the...
- get The Tightwad Gazette the tightwad way: for free! The Frugal Blogroll is about to break the 300 member...
- Winner of The Tightwad Gazette Before announcing the winner of our latest giveaway, we need...

22 Responses to “Share your failure and win a copy of The Tightwad Gazette”
February 6th, 2010 at 8:15 am
Building Your House On The Wrong Property!!!! That sounds like a hell of a story!!!!
I can’t think of a major failure of my own apart from buying cheap stuff and then it breaking on me, however one of my good friends has a story that always makes me laugh. He was traveling in France with his best friend and they wanted to stick to a very strict budget. So they decided they would go beach combing and find seafood in the form of shell fish. That evening they had a superb dinner of mussels and other shell fish cooked over an open fire using some butter they had purchased. They said it tasted great but then the next morning they were both in agony and were rushed to the hospital where their food poisoning was dealt with and they were landed a big bill that wiped out all their savings for traveling the rest of the globe!
February 6th, 2010 at 9:00 am
I always have GREAT plans of turning old torn jeans into a purse for my DD or a quilt or something grand. I don’t even own a sewing machine. And even if I did, I don’t really even know how to use one. So, it’s the space and effort to “try” and save them, thinking about using them, etc. Just to be decluttering and throw them away…
February 6th, 2010 at 9:36 am
I already have a copy! I’m sure I’ve had several of these “worst” things happen over the years, but the first that comes to mind is that I used to buy cheap, cheap shoes and wear them until they broke. Then I got plantar fasciitis and many doctors visits and expensive orthotics later I learned that I brought this on myself from wearing cheap shoes with no arches. A good example of penny wise, pound foolish.
February 6th, 2010 at 9:39 am
I wasn’t planning on having a third baby – especially given the divorce, so when I moved out on my own I started purging baby stuff slowly, the girls being 2 and 4. A year after I got rid of the last of it? My new husband and I had been together for 2, and found ourselves expecting again.
I didn’t replace most of it, but was sad to have liquidated my cloth diaper stash :/
February 6th, 2010 at 9:55 am
We were going to St. Simon’s Beach, GA for a great time at the beach and I had the brilliant
idea that we would camp at the campsite there on the island to save money instead of a hotel room.. We got there and set up the tent and sleeping blankets under a firestorm of biting mosquitos and bugs. Then we went to the beach and had fun. That night we returned to our tent and it was soaked from a rainstorm earlier, the
tent obviously didn’t hold up or we put it up wrong or something. The mosquitos were worse than ever as we dismantled our tent and wet sleeping bags. We spent the night in an expensive
hotel room anyway. What a miserable trip!
February 6th, 2010 at 12:52 pm
My last house came with a circa 1970 gold colored stove/oven. We had no money to purchase new appliances for the foreseeable future so I decided that I would improve the appearance of this appliance by giving it a really good cleaning. I spent the better part of one day cleaning the oven, the stove element rings, etc. I even removed the glass window from the front of the oven, took it apart and cleaned the drips that were between the 2 panes of glass. The stove was looking pretty good, however, the first time I turned on the oven the glass window broke. I managed to find a replacement (which I could not afford and unfortunately, I had to borrow money to buy!!!!). The appliance repair shop told me that one pane of glass in a stove is tempered and one is not and it will brake if you put put the untempered side of the window on the inside of your oven. It just goes to show no good deed goes unpunished….
February 6th, 2010 at 2:44 pm
As a newlywed, trying to be smart with our food budget, I discovered TVP (textured vegetable protein). I started replacing some of the ground beef in my husband’s favorite recipes with this new wonder food, TVP. He raved about my cooking, so I kept increasing the TVP-to-meat ratio in his meals. After a month of increasing TVP, I finally found out that my enthusiasm for TVP was causing my husband major distress in the gastrointestinal and bathroom departments… Sorry Honey! And since I’m a vegetarian, I was immune and oblivious for way too long…
February 6th, 2010 at 3:10 pm
We hired my hubby’s drinking buddy who is a carpenter to help us renovate our house because, he wouldn’t charge us much since he was a friend. Big mistake! Because he was paid cheaply, and because he was a drinking buddy, (they spend most of their working time drinking and working half corked )most of the work was half ass done or sloppily and we are now redoing everything! 10′s of thousands of $$ down the drain!
February 6th, 2010 at 8:00 pm
I decided that rather than buying cheap shoes that fell apart, I would buy expensive shoes, on the rationale that they would last longer and be cheaper in the long run. So I went and bought two pairs of shoes from a fancy German brand.
Both pairs starting looking worn within six months and fell apart completely inside of a year. So much for that great idea.
February 6th, 2010 at 10:05 pm
Can’t think of any great failure, but I always manage to leave my coupons at home for anything not large grocery shopping related.
February 7th, 2010 at 8:53 am
I had this great idea to collect sticks and limbs from our backyard to burn in our fireplace for warmth on those cold days instead of buying firewood. We canceled our yard waste pick up and I filled our fire place with sticks and set a fire. Those sticks were burnt in less than five minutes. I had a messy fireplace to clean and no nice heat from our free source. We still use those sticks but now they are used as kindling.
February 7th, 2010 at 11:00 pm
After Christmas my husband and I and our 5 month old were traveling from the middle of the US to the east coast to visit his family. (They really wanted to see there grandaughter.)Because of the long trip with a nursing baby we knew we would have to spend the night half way. It was just way too long of a trip expecially with the added time of having to stop every three hours to feed a baby. So I did the frugalish thing (I know the really frugal thing would have been to not even need an hotel but we had decided it was a essential to have rest and be in one peice when we got to our destination.) and bid on a hotel from priceline. I put in a low big and landed a room for $35 at a Holiday Inn! I was really excited! i decided that we didn’t need to spend the extra $5 on incase we need to cancel. But I didn’t foresee the snow! We followed a snow storm the whole way the first day and had to pull off 2-3 hours before we got to our hotel and find another one because the roads were so hazardous. So instead of paying an extra $5 so we could change the hotel we paid $80 for an extra room when we had to stop.
February 8th, 2010 at 9:34 am
Oh, like a previous poster I always leave my coupons at home!!! I shouldn’t giggle, but it makes me feel better to hear I’m not the only one who does that.
My big frugal nightmare was when we saved for months to purchase a used car for our small family, but skipped the expensive (we thought) vehicle inspection…big mistake. We thought the inspection was a waste of money??? More like the lemon we bought was a waste of money. We definitely learned a lesson from that experience!
February 8th, 2010 at 12:32 pm
There have been more than a few but my most typical frugal failing is going to the market with a couple of coupons that were expiring and were really a good deal and walking out of the store with far too many items that I did not need to buy just then.
The moral of the story: Sometimes frugality can cost more than it can save.
February 8th, 2010 at 8:32 pm
Frugal: buying a farm share at a local organic farm so that we could get fresh organic produce each week for an 8 month period.
Not-so-frugal: giving away all the fresh organic produce that we didn’t like to eat (beets, kale, collards…).
We did like some of the produce, but it was sad when we got produce in our weekly share that no one in the house liked to eat.
Now I just go to local farm stands and just buy the produce we like to eat.
February 9th, 2010 at 4:46 pm
Last week I dropped $40 out of my pocket at the farmer’s market because I didn’t feel like lugging my purse. So, I had to go the ATM to get more cash and paid $6 in fees. Ugh! I also keep intending to shop at thrift stores and talk myself out of it when I see great sales online.
February 10th, 2010 at 11:17 am
A few different times I’ve tried to save money by buying a cheap ($1 or so) new lipstick or eye shadow instead of using the color and brand I already know works. Instead, I end up with like five really ugly shades that I throw out and end up buying the “tried and true” anyway.
February 10th, 2010 at 7:55 pm
Well, maybe I should blushingly admit that my worst frugal move has been to NOT have this book.
But I think my hubby and I would agree that the worst mistake we made was going in with a friend on a cow. Half a beef in our freezer, and we hated every bite (not having a taste at the time for grass-fed beef). I would say that close to 200 pounds of it went *gulp* into the dogs’ dish or the garbage. So many other things we could have done with it…such an embarrassing memory.
February 11th, 2010 at 11:27 am
We bought a live Christmas tree one year with the idea that we’d plant it outside and have another pine tree in the yard. So we spent the big bucks on the live tree and it died in the spring.
Learned our lesson – we buy cut trees or make do with an artificial tree. No more expensive live Christmas trees for us!
February 11th, 2010 at 10:07 pm
I researched and bought some Austrees on ebay for a good price. I watered them every day because I didn’t want them to die. That was until I got a $200 water bill!!!! opps! My cheap trees suddenly weren’t so cheap!
February 15th, 2010 at 10:28 pm
I bought 20 pks of Kraft cheese with coupons. I paid 50 cents a pack. I kept them in the fridge in the basement. One of my neices took them out and left them on the floor. I found them a few days later. I had to throw them out. I was soooo sad.
February 21st, 2010 at 9:56 am
One week I decided to try to make a caramel pie otherwise the only place I could get it was at %5.00 a slice at a restaurant. I tried using my grandmothers recipe where you can place Eagle Brand milk can in boiling water. I got busy and let the boiling water dry up as it takes several hours to make this caramelize. I heard a loud bang from upstairs. When I got downstairs immediately I saw the can of Eagle Brand Milk in the next room empty. The caramel was on the stove, cabinets, ceiling, and floor. I took me weeks to clean this all up as thick sticky caramel as it is hard to get up. I even had to repaint the ceiling. From now on when I try to make this recipe I set a timer for every 30 minutes to check the water level.
Leave a Comment